Senate to vote this week on legislation that would weaken Clean Water Act protections & limit tribal input on projects that impact their historic sites & natural resources 

WASHINGTON, D.C.  –Today, U.S. Senator Maria Cantwell (D-WA), a senior member of the Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, joined tribal, outdoor recreation, and conservation leaders for a virtual press conference to push back on a permitting reform proposal that would undermine tribal nations and weaken protections for our waters, land, and wildlife.

The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, or BAAJA, is being voted on by the Senate this week. If the Senate passes the bill, it may be taken up by the House of Representatives before the end of the year.

“Don’t sacrifice the Clean Water Act, or hunting or fishing grounds, historic or sacred sites, or protections of tribal sovereignty,” said Sen. Cantwell. “We all need new sources of energy and power. I’ve been committed to that my whole time in the United States Senate. But this bill, as it’s currently drafted, is not the answer.”

“The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act is the single greatest threat to our ability to protect our sacred spaces, our ancestors, traditional ceremonies, and our culture in decades,” said Oneida Vice Chair Jameson Wilson (WI). “Any effort to accelerate development must strengthen, not diminish and erode tribal sovereignty and meaningful consultation. If we and other tribes across the country had been consulted by the authors of this bill or been able to submit feedback through the regular legislative process, we could have helped draft a bill that gives developers the certainty they need to build on federal and tribal land, while still ensuring we are able to protect our sacred spaces. However, this bill was drafted in secret by four senators without any tribal input, not a single congressional hearing or vote, and now it is being fast tracked for passage.”

“One of BAAJA’s most insidious and hidden attacks on clean water is through codifying changes to the Clean Water Act with regard to the protection of wetlands,” said Brian Chaffin, owner of the Sundog River Guide Company (AK) and Executive Director of the Clark Fork Coalition in Montana. “The act would remove the requirement for Section 404 permits to consider the loss of wildlife habitat and flood control structures, particularly in headwater states like Montana. This has a compounding effect. When we fill wetlands without assessment and mitigation, the impacts of increasing size and intensity of floods will be felt far downstream from Montana to New Orleans. Removing this protection will lead to an increase in flood-related disasters, property damage, loss of life, and the need for emergency federal assistance.”  

“The purpose of environmental laws is not simply to provide remedies after harm occurs; it is to help us make sound decisions before that harm becomes irreversible,” said Yakama Tribal Councilmember John Washines (WA). “You cannot bring back an extinct salmon run with an after-the-fact apology. My people have already paid far too much for this country’s energy development. We should not be asked to sacrifice our salmon and our treaty rights yet again.”

“The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act jeopardizes land, water, and access critical to the $1.2 trillion outdoor industry economy,” said Corley Kenna, head of communications and policy for Patagonia Outdoor Clothing & Gear. “This bill will weaken bedrock environmental laws, undermine tribal nation sovereignty, and make it harder for state governments and the public to challenge harmful extractive projects if the bill is passed in its current form. Provisions could lock in drilling, mining, logging, and other development on public lands with little to no opportunity to undo those actions — threatening wildlife, clean water, and culturally significant areas.”

“The Prairie Band Potawatomi Nation supports responsible economic development and permitting reform,” said Prairie Band Potawatomi Nation Chairman Joseph “Zeke” Rupnick (KS). “However, reform cannot come at the expense of tribal sovereignty, sacred places, natural resources, or the federal government’s legal obligations to tribal nations. We call upon Congress to halt advancements of BAAJA until meaningful government-to-government consultation occurs.”

“The BAAJA drafting process has been rushed and it’s deeply flawed. The project certainty provision within it weakens states’ rights, and we — business owners, and all citizens — lose local control and our own voices,” said Grant Bixby, realtor and volunteer leader of the Business Alliance for Protecting the Pacific Coast (CA). “We can’t afford BAAJA. It risks harming our waters and lands upon which our businesses depend. In California, offshore mineral resources makes up 1% of our marine economy employment, should we put the other 99% of our employment at risk of closure and devastation? I think not.”

BAAJA would:

  • Limit public input: Impose new deadlines and restrictions on lawsuits challenging federal environmental decisions, while limiting courts’ ability to halt certain projects even when violations are identified.
  • Undermine tribal sovereignty and protections for sacred sites: Rewrite federal historic preservation requirements, impose new deadlines on tribal consultation, and limit certain legal challenges—weakening Tribal Nations’ ability to influence federal decisions affecting their ancestral lands, sacred sites, and cultural resources.
  • Reduce environmental review: Expand circumstances in which projects can proceed without a full federal environmental review and narrow the alternatives considered.
  • Change clean water and wetlands protections: Revise state water-quality certification, wetlands permitting, and judicial review procedures.
  • Alter endangered species protections: Change federal consultation and review requirements affecting salmon, steelhead, and other protected species.
  • Restrict agency flexibility after project approval: Establish new limitations on modifying or revoking certain federal permits.

Sen. Cantwell is one of the Senate’s staunchest protectors of our public lands. She led the 12-year-long battle to stop the Pebble Mine in Bristol Bay, Alaska, which would have devastated one of the world’s largest salmon runs. Last year she led the fight against GOP proposals to sell public lands to the highest bidder. 

Video of today’s virtual press conference is available HERE; a transcript is HERE.